Cocktails, Crab Cakes, and Dueling Pianos: Why Mayflower the Encore Is Troy’s Hidden Gem

 TROY, Ohio – Music, handcrafted cocktails, and mouthwatering dishes are drawing packed crowds to one of downtown Troy’s most stunning revivals—Mayflower the Encore.

Once a 1920s theater and later a cinema, this historic venue has been reimagined into a one-of-a-kind restaurant and entertainment destination. Now, it’s the talk of the town—and there’s a limited-time reason to check it out.

Every Wednesday this month, guests who mention the “Pitts Stop” video at Mayflower the Encore will receive 20% off their meal as part of a local spotlight promotion.

A Grand Comeback with Character

Located in the heart of Troy, Mayflower the Encore blends old-world charm with modern flair. From its restored theater walls to its vintage bar and balcony seating, the ambiance is nothing short of cinematic.

“It’s one of a kind,” said Wes, the visionary behind the venue’s revival. “We got the building in 2022 and have worked nonstop to bring it back to life. Now, we’ve got dueling pianos, great food, and a space that makes every night feel special.”

Food and Drinks Made with Heart

Whether you're sipping a handcrafted Old Fashioned or enjoying a Strawberry Fields cocktail—crafted in partnership with Cherry Street Bottle Shop—you’ll taste the passion in every pour. The menu offers elevated yet approachable dishes like blackened salmon, arugula salad with cranberries, and crab cakes that are “on point,” according to one returning guest.

“I want every night here to be the best night of someone’s life,” said Ally, one of the bartenders whose cocktails are made “with love.”

Entertainment That Fills the House

On select nights, dueling pianos take center stage in the old theater room, turning dinner into a full-blown experience. From upbeat renditions of “American Pie” to packed-house singalongs, the energy is infectious.

“There’s not a bad seat in the house,” said Wes, who grew up just down the road in West Milton. “This is a place where food, music, and community all come together.”

A Local Favorite with a Limited-Time Deal

Mayflower the Encore is quickly becoming a go-to for anniversaries, date nights, and celebrations of all kinds. Angie, a longtime local, called it “a gem” and praised its transformation.

To make the most of your visit, stop by on Wednesdays through the end of the month and mention the “Pitts Stop” video for 20% off your meal.

“This is your invitation,” said Wes. “We’re just getting started.”